I am going to be honest here- I have never heard of the Italian Love Cake until I found this recipe card in a random recipe box that I found at Amvets. Should we tell Candy Rinaldo that the card she so nicely wrote out ended up at the thrift? I did find some random websites that claimed that this cake was “made famous” by Mario Batali but this card appears to date before he made it famous. Who knows. It does look super-rich and sweet though.
Today in things I had not heard of until today- the South Buffalo Cake. Who knew that there was a cake named after a neighborhood here in the 716. I don’t know what makes this particular cake so special to South Buffalo (to play along with stereotypes there is nothing Irish about it). I was only able to find two other hits with the name of this recipe- one (with a chocolate glaze) was on another recipe website and the other was someone asking about it.
One of the key things to remember when doing baking is to use the correct type of flour for the recipe. Cake flour (which is what is called for in this recipe) has a lower protein content (10%) than all-purpose (King Arthur is 11.7%) and bread flour (King Arthur is 12.7%)
The name of this recipe is so misleading- I expected for it to be an “ice cream cake”, not a chocolate cake with ice cream. This recipe can be tailored to your needs so easily. Want regular chocolate cake? Buy that mix. Need to go gluten-free? There is a mix for that. You can even make your own from scratch (see a list of cake recipes at the bottom of this post)
Insert a super long story about how this Fabulous Fudge Cake recipe was handed down by generations of women. It wasn’t. It came in a 3 pronged folder with a bunch of other cut out recipes that I got at the Salvation Army (back when they still had the as-is store (shakes fist at Covid-19)
Bake at 375° for 25-30 minutes. Makes one 9" triple layer cake
Cook Time30 minutesmins
Course: after church coffee hour, Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: cake, chocolate cake
Equipment
Set of 3 nine-inch cake pans
Ingredients
3squares unsweetened chocolate
2¼cupssifted cake flour
2teaspoonsbaking soda
½teaspoonsalt
½cupbutter or margarine
2¼cupsfirmly packed brown sugar
3eggs
2teaspoonsvanilla
½cupbuttermilk
1cupboiling water
Instructions
Grease bottoms of 3 nine inch layer-cake pans; line pans with Waxed paper; grease paper.
Melt chocolate in a small saucepan over very low heat; save for Step 5.
Sift cake flour, baking soda, and salt onto waxed paper.
Cream butter or margarine in a large bowl with a spoon or electric mixer at medium speed; gradually add sugar; beat until mixture is fluffy.
Beat in eggs, 1 at a time; beat until thick stir in vanilla and chocolate with spoon or mixer at low speed.
Add sifted dry ingredients, a third at a time alternately with buttermilk, stirring by hand or with mixer at low speed until just blended; stir in boiling water. Pour into pans.
Bake in moderate oven (375°) 25-30 minutes, or until centers spring back when lightly pressed with fingertip.
Cool in pans on wire racks 5 minutes; loosen around edges with knife; turn out onto racks; remove wax paper; cool completely. Put layers together and frost.
Makes enough to fill and frost 1 9″triple-layer cake
Course: after church coffee hour, cake
Cuisine: American
Keyword: cake, chocolate, frosting
Equipment
double boiler
Ingredients
2squares unsweetened chocolate
2tablespoonsbutter or margarine
1cup 10X confectioners’ powdered sugarsifted
¼teaspoonsalt
1egg
1cup cream for whipping
1teaspoonvanilla
Instructions
Melt chocolate and butter or margarine on top of a large double boiler over hot, not boiling, water; beat in sugar, salt, and egg until smooth
Place the top of the double boiler over ice in a large bowl; start beating with an electric mixer or rotary beater, gradually adding cream; continue beating 3 to 4 minutes, or until fluffy-thick; stir in vanilla.
Keep frosting over ice as you work, Chill cake until serving time
Here is where I go on and on about the fluffy snowflake I saw outside of my window this morning and the purring of my cat. Google is a fickle creature and ranks sites with long & boring stories higher.